Category:Is-Philly Neighborhood - Revision history

Stan: /* Editor's Notes */

2021-09-30T11:39:24Z

Editor's Notes

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:39, 30 September 2021
Line 6:		Line 6:
	*I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan		*I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan
	*To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when naming Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. I believe that every category that appears on a category page should be in the same top cat as the category page; a Where should be a subcategory to only other Wheres; an Is should a subcategory to only other Is's, etc. --Paul		*To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when naming Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. I believe that every category that appears on a category page should be in the same top cat as the category page; a Where should be a subcategory to only other Wheres; an Is should a subcategory to only other Is's, etc. --Paul
			* Paul, how can we host a list of all Philadelphia neighborhoods using your criteria? -- Stan

	[[Category:Is]]		[[Category:Is]]

PaulSank: minor improvement

2019-12-28T04:03:27Z

minor improvement

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:03, 28 December 2019
Line 5:		Line 5:
	==Editor's Notes==		==Editor's Notes==
	*I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan		*I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan
	*To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when naming Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. I believe that every category that appears on a category page should be in the same top cat as the category page; a Where is a subcategory to only other Wheres; an Is is a subcategory to only other Is's, etc. --Paul		*To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when naming Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. I believe that every category that appears on a category page should be in the same top cat as the category page; a Where should be a subcategory to only other Wheres; an Is should a subcategory to only other Is's, etc. --Paul

	[[Category:Is]]		[[Category:Is]]

PaulSank: minor improvement

2019-12-28T04:02:31Z

minor improvement

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:02, 28 December 2019
Line 5:		Line 5:
	==Editor's Notes==		==Editor's Notes==
	*I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan		*I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan
	*To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when naming Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. --Paul		*To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when naming Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. I believe that every category that appears on a category page should be in the same top cat as the category page; a Where is a subcategory to only other Wheres; an Is is a subcategory to only other Is's, etc. --Paul

	[[Category:Is]]		[[Category:Is]]

PaulSank: minor improvement

2019-12-28T03:58:17Z

minor improvement

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:58, 27 December 2019
Line 1:		Line 1:
	==See Also==		==See Also==
			*[[:Category:Where-Philadelphia\|Category:Where-Philadelphia]]
	*[[Neighborhoods]]		*[[Neighborhoods]]
	*[[:Category:Where-Philadelphia\|Category:Where-Philadelphia]]

	==Editor's Notes==		==Editor's Notes==

PaulSank: minor correction

2019-12-28T03:30:15Z

minor correction

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:30, 27 December 2019
Line 5:		Line 5:
	==Editor's Notes==		==Editor's Notes==
	*I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan		*I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan
	*To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when ~~namining~~ Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. --Paul		*To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when naming Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. --Paul

	[[Category:Is]]		[[Category:Is]]

PaulSank: minor improvement

2019-12-28T03:29:44Z

minor improvement

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:29, 27 December 2019
Line 4:		Line 4:

	==Editor's Notes==		==Editor's Notes==
	I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan		*I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan
	To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when namining Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. --Paul		*To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when namining Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. --Paul

	[[Category:Is]]		[[Category:Is]]

PaulSank: minor correction

2019-12-28T03:28:23Z

minor correction

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:28, 27 December 2019
Line 1:		Line 1:
	==See Also==		==See Also==
	*[[Neighborhoods]]		*[[Neighborhoods]]
	*[[:Category:Where-Philadelphia\|Category:Where-Philadelphia]		*[[:Category:Where-Philadelphia\|Category:Where-Philadelphia]]

	==Editor's Notes==		==Editor's Notes==

PaulSank: See Also item added

2019-12-28T03:27:59Z

PaulSank: note added

2019-12-28T03:26:30Z

note added

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:26, 27 December 2019
Line 1:		Line 1:
	See Also: <u>[[Neighborhoods]]</u><Br>		See Also: <u>[[Neighborhoods]]</u><Br>
	I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan		I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan
			To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when namining Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. --Paul

	[[Category:Is]]		[[Category:Is]]

Stan at 05:19, 7 September 2019

2019-09-07T05:19:02Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:19, 7 September 2019
Line 1:		Line 1:
	See Also [[Neighborhoods]]<Br>		See Also: <u>[[Neighborhoods]]</u><Br>
	I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan		I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan
	[[Category:Is]]		[[Category:Is]]

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:27, 27 December 2019
Line 1:		Line 1:
	See Also~~: <u>~~[[Neighborhoods]]~~</u><Br>~~		==See Also==
			*[[Neighborhoods]]
			*[[:Category:Where-Philadelphia\|Category:Where-Philadelphia]

			==Editor's Notes==
	I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan		I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan
	To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when namining Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. --Paul		To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when namining Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. --Paul

	[[Category:Is]]		[[Category:Is]]